Vilfredo Pareto
Według Pareta większość ludzkich działań wynika nie z logiki, lecz z trwałych uczuć, które ludzie potem przyodziewają w racje; nauka musi trzymać się faktów obserwowanych, a te pokazują historię jako nieustanną cyrkulację elit.
Umiejscowienie
Inżynier, ekonomista i socjolog, który nauczał w Lozannie: w ekonomii zdefiniował kryterium efektywności zwane dziś optimum Pareta; w socjologii wyjaśniał działanie społeczne w dużej mierze motywami nielogicznymi, a historię jako „cyrkulację elit”.
Kluczowe idee
- Optimum Pareta
- Działanie nielogiczne
- Rezydua i derywacje
- Cyrkulacja elit
Wpływ
Wpływ na 1
Talcott Parsons
wpływ na
Parsons devoted part of The Structure of Social Action (1937) to Pareto, reading his theory of non-logical action and residues as converging on a voluntaristic theory of action. T. Parsons, The Structure of Social Action (1937), part II; V. Pareto, Trattato di sociologia generale (1916)
Źródło: szkic AI
Talcott Parsons › 1902–1979
Krytyka
Krytyka ze strony 1
Gaetano Mosca
krytyka ze strony
Mosca accused Pareto of presenting the theory of a ruling minority, set out in Mosca’s Elementi di scienza politica (1896), as his own elite theory without acknowledgement. G. Mosca, Elementi di scienza politica (1896; 2nd ed. 1923); J. H. Meisel, The Myth of the Ruling Class: Gaetano Mosca and the Elite (1958)
Źródło: szkic AI
Gaetano Mosca › 1858–1941
Krytykuje 1
Karol Marks
krytykuje
Pareto rejected Marx’s labour theory of value and recast class struggle as a perpetual circulation of elites, which no revolution ends (Les systèmes socialistes, 1902–03). V. Pareto, Les systèmes socialistes (1902–03); Trattato di sociologia generale (1916)
Źródło: szkic AI
Karol Marks › 1818–1883
Dzieła
Rozwija ekonomię równowagi ogólnej na podstawie wyborów i krzywych obojętności oraz definiuje stan, w którym nikomu nie można poprawić sytuacji, nie pogarszając sytuacji komuś innemu.
Rozległe studium działania nielogicznego: trwałe uczucia („rezydua”) i budowane na nich uzasadnienia („derywacje”) wyjaśniają wiele z życia społecznego oraz wzlot i upadek elit.
Stanowisko
Pareto is on the map for two bodies of work that are rarely read together. As an economist of the Lausanne school he developed Walras’s theory of general equilibrium and, using Edgeworth’s indifference curves, based it on the ranking of choices rather than on measurable utility. In the “Manual” (1906) he defined the state in which no one can be made better off without making someone else worse off; welfare economics adopted this as the Pareto criterion, Rawls discussed it as the principle of efficiency in “A Theory of Justice”, and Amartya Sen showed its conflict with minimal liberal rights (1970). As a sociologist he held that most action is non-logical: constant “residues” are clothed in changing “derivations”, and governing elites – cunning “foxes” and forceful “lions”, an image taken from Machiavelli – rise and decay; history, he wrote, is a graveyard of aristocracies. Talcott Parsons counted him among the founders of the theory of action (1937); Mosca accused him of taking over his own theory of the ruling class. The theory of residues has often been criticised as vague and hard to test. In 1923 Pareto welcomed Mussolini’s government but in his last articles demanded that freedom of the press and of teaching be preserved; fascist propaganda claimed him as a forerunner. Whether he can be regarded as a precursor of fascism is disputed (R. Cirillo, 1983).
Życie i kontekst
Vilfredo Pareto was born on 15 July 1848 in Paris, the son of a Genoese nobleman who had gone into exile as a follower of Mazzini, and a French mother; the family returned to Italy in the 1850s. He studied mathematics and engineering in Turin and graduated from the engineering school there in 1870. For some twenty years he worked as an engineer and manager, first for the Roman railway company in Florence, then at the head of an iron company in the Valdarno, while campaigning as a liberal for free trade and against the protectionist and military policies of Italian governments. In 1889 he married Alessandra Bakunin. Encouraged by the economist Maffeo Pantaleoni, he turned to economic theory and in 1893 succeeded Léon Walras in the chair of political economy at the University of Lausanne. An inheritance in 1898 made him financially independent, and he settled in Céligny on Lake Geneva; after the end of his first marriage he lived with Jeanne Régis, whom he married in 1923. In poor health, he gradually gave up teaching. In 1923 Mussolini asked him to represent Italy on the disarmament commission of the League of Nations and appointed him a senator, but Pareto did not sign the deed of appointment. He died in Céligny on 19 August 1923.
Dalsze główne dzieła
- Course of Political Economy (Cours d’économie politique, 1896–97)
- The Socialist Systems (Les systèmes socialistes, 1902–03)
- Manual of Political Economy (Manuale di economia politica, 1906)
- Treatise on General Sociology / The Mind and Society (Trattato di sociologia generale, 1916)
- The Transformation of Democracy (Trasformazione della democrazia, 1921)
Stan na listopad 2026 · Źródła · Ulepsz tę stronę · Jak powstaje Agora