Abdolkarim Soroush
Sama religia się nie zmienia, ale zmienia się nasze jej rozumienie, wraz z całą naszą pozostałą wiedzą; więc żadnej interpretacji państwo nie może ustalić jako ostatecznej.
Umiejscowienie
Irański filozof wykształcony w chemii i filozofii nauki w Londynie; po pracy w Sztabie Rewolucji Kulturalnej powołanym w 1980 roku został krytykiem rządów duchownych i dowodził, że sama religia jest niezmienna, ale ludzka wiedza o religii jest historyczna i kurczy się oraz rozszerza wraz z całą pozostałą wiedzą.
Kluczowe idee
- Kurczenie się i rozszerzanie wiedzy religijnej
- Religia jest trwalsza niż ideologia
- Demokracja religijna
- Rozszerzanie doświadczenia proroczego
Wpływ
Pod wpływem 2
Mulla Sadra
pod wpływem
Soroush’s early book The Restless Nature of the World (1978) expounded Mulla Sadra’s doctrine of substantial motion, the constant change in the substance of things. A. Soroush, Nahad-e na-aram-e jahan (1978); M. Sadri & A. Sadri (eds.), Reason, Freedom, and Democracy in Islam (2000)
Źródło: szkic AI
Mulla Sadra › ok. 1572–1640
Karl Popper
pod wpływem
Soroush took up Popper’s fallibilism for his theory that religious knowledge, unlike religion itself, is human, historical and revisable (The Contraction and Expansion of Religious Knowledge, 1990). A. Soroush, Qabz va bast-e teorik-e shariat (1990); M. Sadri & A. Sadri (eds.), Reason, Freedom, and Democracy in Islam (2000)
Źródło: także w InPhO · InPhO
Karl Popper › 1902–1994
Krytyka
Krytykuje 1
Ali Szari’ati
krytykuje
Soroush criticised Shariati’s turning of Islam into a revolutionary ideology, arguing that religion is richer than any ideology (‘Loftier than Ideology’, 1994). ʿA. Soroush, Farbehtar az ideolozhi, 1994; Reason, Freedom, and Democracy in Islam, tr. M. Sadri & A. Sadri, 2000
Źródło: szkic AI
Ali Szari’ati › 1933–1977
Dzieła
Eseje opublikowane po raz pierwszy w latach 1988–90: religia nie jest tożsama z ludzkim jej rozumieniem, a to rozumienie zmienia się wraz z filozofią, nauką i pytaniami każdej epoki.
Objawienie jest rozumiane jako doświadczenie prorockie, które rosło wraz z życiem Proroka i jego wspólnoty, tak że jego historyczną formę można odróżnić od jego rdzenia.
Stanowisko
Soroush distinguishes between religion itself and human knowledge of religion. Religion, as revelation, does not change; but our understanding of it is a human, fallible and historical form of knowledge that stands in exchange with all other knowledge – philosophy, science, the questions of each age – and therefore contracts and expands with it. From this it follows that no interpretation can claim final authority and that the clergy has no monopoly on understanding Islam. In “Sturdier than Ideology” (1994) he criticised the turning of religion into a political ideology, as in the work of Ali Shariati: an ideology is a rigid weapon for struggle, while religion is richer and must remain open. He argued for a “religious democratic government” in which faith is freely held and human rights and justice are understood as having a basis outside religion. In “The Expansion of Prophetic Experience” (1999) and in later interviews he described revelation as the prophetic experience of Muhammad, shaped by his person and his historical world, a view that led to sharp responses from leading clerics. His thought is marked by Popper’s fallibilism and by the mystical poetry of Rumi, whose Masnavi he edited.
Życie i kontekst
Abdolkarim Soroush, born Hossein Haj Faraj Dabbagh on 16 December 1945 in Tehran, studied pharmacy at the University of Tehran. In 1973 he went to London, where he studied analytical chemistry and then the history and philosophy of science at Chelsea College, and was active among Muslim Iranian students. He returned to Iran after the revolution of 1979 and taught at the Teacher Training University in Tehran. In 1980 Ayatollah Khomeini appointed him to the Cultural Revolution Headquarters, which closed the universities and reorganised them along Islamic lines; the extent of his responsibility for the purges of that period is disputed. From 1988 to 1990 his essays on the “contraction and expansion” of religious knowledge appeared in the journal Keyhan-e Farhangi and made him the leading figure of Iranian religious reform thought. In the 1990s his lectures were disrupted by vigilante groups and he lost his academic positions. Since 2000 he has lived and taught mostly abroad, among other places at Harvard, Yale and Princeton.
Dalsze główne dzieła
- The Restless Nature of the World (Nahād-e nā-ārām-e jahān, 1978)
- The Theoretical Contraction and Expansion of the Shariʿa (1990)
- Sturdier than Ideology (Farbeh-tar az ideolozhi, 1994)
- Straight Paths (Serāthā-ye mostaqim, 1998)
- The Expansion of Prophetic Experience (1999)
- Reason, Freedom, and Democracy in Islam (2000)
Stan na listopad 2026 · Źródła · Ulepsz tę stronę · Jak powstaje Agora